Top Five Modern Protest Songs
Image by Evgeny Parfenov
There's a hell of a lot to be angry about nowadays. The result of the last general election, the London riots, political and economic unrest around the globe, the rising price of Tesco Value Noodles (I swear they used to cost, like, 9p) - and where did the loudest, righteous outcries come from in the past? Music! From Bob Dylan through to Billy Bragg to Kathleen Hanna and taking in select punk bands on the way (because most were pretty basic, even as sloganeering politics goes), there's a rich tradition in modern music of the protest song.
Can you name a good one from, say, the last five or even ten years, though? All we've got now is the Sex Pistols aesthetic filtered down to Donny Tourette, or Frank Turner sounding like uh Donny Tourette. Whatever happened to the protest song?
1. Thom Yorke - Harrowdown Hill
Option one: It got a little more subtle. The stand-out track from the Radiohead frontman's debut (and thus far only) solo album, Thom Yorke described 'Harrowdown Hill' as "the most angry song [he'd] ever written in [his] life," not that you'd get that impression from listening to it. Rather than write a fiery, angry rant about the shady circumstances surrounding the supposed suicide of weapons expert Dr David Kelly, following revelations concerning his leaking of government information about WMDs in Iraq, Yorke chose to sing from the perspective of Kelly himself, to great effect. With a low-key, foreboding backing, Yorke sings hauntingly "Did I fall or was I pushed? And where's the blood?," and directs listeners elsewhere for answers: "Don't ask me, ask the Ministry."
2. Pussy Riot - Punk Prayer
Option two: It's still happening overseas. As fun as Police Academy 7: Mission to Moscow was, Russia does not seem like a great place to live. Did you know they recently renewed a ban on Gay Pride marches for another hundred years? And this from a president who releases photos of himself like this. Pussy Riot are a stunning, brave, and truly vital revitalisation of the riot grrl movement. This is the song that landed the group in hot water (to put it mildly) when they performed it in a Russian church, the chorus being "Virgin Mary, Mother of God, banish Putin, banish Putin / Virgin Mary, Mother of God, banish him, we pray thee!...Virgin Mary, Mother of God / Be a feminist, we pray thee." Three of the members are now serving prison sentences for the performance, which only goes further to highlight the power of the protest song, as well as just how messed up Russia is.
3. Bloc Party - Hunting For Witches
Option three: There's a right way (and a wrong way) to do it. On their forthcoming new album, Four, Bloc Party have a song about the London riots called 'Kettling'. And it's awful. It's shallow, it's cheesy - sung from the perspective of some oh-so-rebellious rioters - and generally a bit crap. 'Hunting For Witches', from second LP A Weekend In The City, meanwhile, is a triumph. Directly attacking right-wing media and their reactionary, fear-mongering response to the 7/7 London bombings, Kele and co. manage to be funny in a gallows humour sort of way - "The Daily Mail says the enemy's among us / Taking our women and taking our jobs" - whilst maintaining a feel of fear, desperation and anger with the glitchy, anxious guitars and samples.
4. Kate Nash - Mansion Song
Option four: It's not where you expect to find it. Everyone through a shit fit when they heard that the singer of 'Foundations' had gone all weird and arty and distortion-friendly on a recent new demo; where were they when My Best Friend Is You came out? Nash's second album includes this little curio, another riot grrrl-influenced track, a nakedly feminist spoken word poem about sexism in the music industry, and society more generally, ending with her own rejection of her expected role as a sex object/mother. Raw, and a little uncomfortable (as anything so confrontational should be), with nary a mention of her face, covered in freckles.
5. The Legendary K.O. - George Bush Doesn't Care About Black People
Option five: It never went away. The natural descendant of the punk protest song was hip-hop, from the "black CNN" of Public Enemy and KRS-One through to even early Kanye West tracks like 'Crack Music'. Whilst the mainstream of hip-hop is leaning further towards the materialistic and the pop-friendly, there's still a rich vein of rebel yells. Taking inspiration from Kanye's rant on live TV about then-President Bush's slow response to the devastation Hurricane Katrina wreaked on New Orleans - and sampling 'Gold Digga' - The Legendary K.O.'s track spread across the Internet, taking their message with it. Catchy, too.
We all love a good pun. Ok, maybe not all of us, but some of us at least. Well I can only actually vouch for myself on this, so at least 0.00000001% of the world's population love a good pun. Every week my fellow HMVers and I are tasked with coming up with puns for new releases, with the latest example for The Hunger Games being "Battle Royale with Cheese," so I'm hoping that this gives me some kind of valid opinion on what a good pun is. [read more]
We are civilised folk, you and I (I'm making this assumption based solely on the fact that you're reading this feature, on this website; hopefully I'm making an ass neither of myself or, er, mption). We see classic rock guitar solos for what they are – masturbatory displays by boring old people who think showing how quickly they can move their fingers up and down a length of wood is more exciting to watch than actually getting on with a song. [read more]
If Jedward isn't overwhelming proof that ridiculous compound words ought not to be plucked from thin air, used in everyday parlance and accepted by society, I don't know what is. Par exemple, I've no problems with the Catholic faith, nor with popular guitar music originating from 1950's America; but meld 'Christian' and 'Rock' and I'm likely to manifest the form of Satan before your very eyes. [read more]
It makes a weird kind of sense that actors would give music a try. Surely, being successful in one sector of show business means diversifying should be a doddle! Enough of them certainly try, and I emphasise the word "try"; seems that it's a fair bit harder than it looks. Maybe more of them should try, I don't know, being trapeze artists. Then we wouldn't end up with Juliette and the Licks. [read more]